OWLS Mary Leonard Chapter
  • Home
  • About Us
    • Board of Directors
    • In Our Community >
      • Archives: Courthouse Connection
      • Archives: 2016 - 2017 Year In Review
      • Archives: 2016 Monte Carlo Casino Night
      • Archives: 2013 New Admittee Luncheon
      • Archives: 2012 New Admittee Luncheon
      • Archives: Photos & Articles 2006 - 2013
    • Who was Mary Leonard?
  • Events
    • Courthouse Connections
    • Imprint Program 2023
    • OWLS Statewide Events
    • Recent Chapter Events >
      • Dec 5, 2022 CLE Experience, Strength & Hope: Destigmatizing Substance Use Disorders & Mental Health in the Legal Profession
      • Nov 30, 2022 New Admittee Luncheon
      • November New Admittee Welcome
      • June 2021 Race Judicata
      • Feb 23, 2021 CLE: The 60th Anniversary of the Freedom RIdes
  • Resources
    • Mid-Valley CourtCare
    • Willamette Women's Law Caucus
    • OWLS Foundation - Grants
  • Contact
  • Contribute

January Arbitration in Marion County Panel Recap

2/14/2013

 
On Tuesday, January 29, 2013, the Mary Leonard Law Society sponsored a one-hour presentation in coordination with the Marion County Circuit Court featuring arbitration in Marion County.  The presentation was held at the Marion County Courthouse.  Panelists included Judge Dale Penn, Marion County Circuit Court and Chair of the Dispute Resolution Commission for Marion County; David A. Hilgemann, Of Counsel, Garrett Hemann Robertson, P.C.; and Michelle Vlach-Ing, Attorney at Law.  The discussion focused on requirements to become a court appointed arbitrator in Marion County; tips for becoming a private arbitrator; and considerations in selecting an arbitrator.

Judge Penn provided an overview of the requirements to become an arbitrator in Marion County, focusing on UTCR Chapter 13, Supplemental Local Rule Chapter 13, and ORS chapter 36.400 to 36.425.  He explained that applicants to become an arbitrator in Marion County must demonstrate five years of practice in good standing with the state bar; must provide three letters of recommendation; and must have participated in at least 10 trials or arbitrations in the practice area for which the applicant seeks to become an arbitrator.  There are three arbitration panels in Marion County:  domestic relations, personal injury, and commercial/real estate. 

Michelle, a court-approved arbitration on the Marion County commercial/real estate panel, noted that each county has different requirements to qualify as an arbitrator and discussed some of those requirements.  For instance, some counties require observation of arbitrations rather than participation.  Michelle reported that Multnomah County requires arbitrator candidates to participate in a one-half day CLE that instructs arbitrators on topics including scheduling arbitrations and providing notice of arbitrations.  She found the CLE to be very helpful.

Judge Penn reported that there has been some discussion by the dispute resolution commission and Marion County judges of amending the requirements to becoming an arbitrator.  The focus of the discussion has been to consider an alternative experience requirement(s) that would allow individuals with other types of experience to become arbitrators.  For instance, pro tem experience might be considered as relevant experience.  Judge Penn noted that the commission values experience and attributes the very low (five percent) appeal rate from arbitrations in Marion County to the quality and experience of arbitrators in Marion County.

The panelists discussed when arbitration is required as well as considerations of when to select arbitration.  Judge Penn stated that some cases are required to go through court-assisted arbitration, such as cases involving $50,000 or less.  If a party fails to appear for court-assisted arbitration, the party may be subject to certain fees following trial depending on the outcome at trial.  Dave suggested that, when a matter involves unusual or novel legal issues, it may be preferable to stay in court rather than to select private arbitration because there is no right to appeal from private arbitration except in very limited circumstances.  He suggested that, when the question is one of damages, arbitration might be preferable to a jury trial because it will typically achieve more predictable results.

Michelle and Dave discussed considerations in selecting an arbitrator.  Both agreed that it is important to inquire about a potential arbitrator’s reputation.  Michelle suggested that, if possible, parties may want to stipulate to an arbitrator and also check with the arbitrator to confirm his or her availability.  Michelle suggested that, in the realm of court-assisted arbitration, she might allow the court to select the arbitrator if the parties could not agree.  With court-assisted arbitration, the parties have the right to appeal from the arbitration. 

Dave suggested several considerations in selecting an arbitrator:  (1) the availability of the arbitrator; (2) the arbitrator’s expertise in the field, noting that an arbitrator with expertise in a particular area of law may be beneficial in some matters, but an arbitrator with expertise may also have preconceived notions about that area of law or the issue presented; (3)  the personality of the arbitrator and whether it would be a good fit with the client; and (4) whether to use one arbitrator or a three-arbitrator panel.

Dave described his experience as a private arbitrator with the Arbitration Service of Portland.  In arbitrations through the Arbitration Service of Portland, a sole arbitrator decides disputes that do not exceed $75,000 and a three-person panel decides disputes over $75,000, unless the parties agree otherwise.  Arbitrators selected through Arbitration Service of Portland may not charge more than $200 per hour for their services.  Dave stated that arbitrators must disclose to the parties any information that they parties might reasonably want to know, such as the arbitrator’s relationship with a party or an attorney.  In his capacity as a private arbitrator, he typically provides written decisions setting forth his reasoning.

The panelists discussed tips for becoming an arbitrator.  The panelists all emphasized the importance of reputation and word of mouth recommendations.  Michelle gained experience with contract disputes by handing hundreds of collections cases as well as taking cases on contingency.  She suggested the modest means program as another way for newer lawyers to gain trial and arbitration experience.  The panel noted that attorneys wishing to become arbitrators may start out in a county with less stringent experience requirements than Marion County.  Judge Penn reported that arbitrators are required by statute to provide notice of the court of the date and time of arbitration.  The court publishes notice on its website.  Those wishing to observe arbitration typically may do so.  Dave offered to arrange for attorneys interested in arbitration to observe one of his arbitrations.  Judge Penn noted that experience as second chair in an arbitration may be pertinent experience. 

February Events with the Mary Leonard Law Society

2/3/2013

 
We look forward to seeing you at one or more MLLS-sponsored events this February, 2013:

The Mary Leonard Law Society and Willamette University College of Law present:
A writing & editing workshop CLE with Professor Suzanne Rowe
Monday, February 11 from 12:00 pm to 1:15 pm
Oregon Civic Justice Center, Hearing Room
790 State Street, Salem Join the Mary Leonard Law Society and Willamette University College of Law for a CLE with author and professor Suzanne Rowe.

A leader in the field of legal writing and the author of six books on legal research, Professor Rowe will provide a fresh look on legal writing and editing techniques.
Banish embarrassing mistakes from your work and create a more error-free legal document! A question and answer period will be provided so bring your writing and editing questions for Professor Rowe.

MLLS lunchtime CLEs are $15 for OWLs members; $20 for non-OWLs members; $10 for judicial clerks; and free to students, WUCL staff and faculty, and to those not seeking CLE credit.
1 MCLE credit pending. Brown bag lunches are encouraged.

The Marion County Bar Association and the Mary Leonard Law Society present:
A Courthouse Connections event: Meet the New Judges
Friday, February 8 from 12:00 pm to 1:00 pmMarion County Courthouse, 5th floor jury assembly room
100 High Street Northeast, Salem
 Please come and meet the newest judges of the Marion County Circuit Court: Judge Don Abar, Judge Vance Day, Judge Courtland Geyer, Judge David Leith and Judge Lindsay Partridge.
Light refreshments generously provided by Sherman, Sherman, Johnnie & Hoyt, LLP.
Brown bag lunches are encouraged.


Winter 2013 Practical Litigation CLE Series and Practical Skills Workshops, presented by the Marion County Bar Association, Mary Leonard Law Society, and the Willamette University College of Law Wednesdays from 3:30 to 5:00 pm, January 16 thru March 13

Please join the MCBA, MLLS, and WUCL for a series of nine weekly seminars on practical litigation skills. Each CLE will be followed by a practical skills workshop, providing an excellent opportunity for new attorneys to meet with experienced practitioners in a small group setting and an ideal shared activity for new admittees and OSB attorney mentors. January presentations are listed below:

February 6, 2013  3:30 – 5:00 pm
“Map, Please! – How to Turn Jury Instructions into a Discovery Plan”
Speaker: James E. Mountain Jr., Harrang Long Gary Rudnick P.C.
Location: Willamette University College of Law, Oregon Civic Justice Center
 
February 13, 2013  3:30 – 5:00 pm
“You Are There: Successful Depositions Reviewed or Reenacted, and Why They Were Effective”
Speaker: Keith J. Bauer, Parks Bauer Sime Winkler & Fernety LLP
Location: Willamette University College of Law, Oregon Civic Justice Center
 
February 20, 2013  3:30 – 5:00 pm
“Getting Your Audience‟s Attention: Using Narratives, Themes and Examples to Tell Your Story”
Speakers: Hon. Martha L. Walters, Associate Justice, Oregon Supreme Court
                 Hon. Tracy A. Prall, Judge, Marion County Circuit Court
                 Mitzi M. Naucler, Legal Aid Services of Oregon
Location: Willamette University College of Law, Oregon Civic Justice Center

February 27, 2013  3:30 – 5:00 pm
“How to Pick „Em: Effective Voir Dire for Civil Juries”
Speaker: Walter H. Sweek, Cosgrave Vergeer Kester LLP 
Location: Willamette University College of Law, Oregon Civic Justice Center

Cost Structure: (cash or check gladly accepted) (OSB CLE credit pending)
$20 per CLE
$100 for CLE series ($90 if payment received by 1/15/13)$15 per CLE for 2010-2012 OSB admittees
$85 for CLE series for 2010-2012 OSB admittees ($75 if payment received by 1/15/13)
Free for practical skills workshops
Light refreshments provided
For advance payment, please send checks made out to MCBA to:
MCBA, c/o William Weidner
PO Box 749
Salem OR 97308
For more information, please contact William Weidner at wweidner@ghrlawyers.com. A complete schedule of events is available for printing or download here.

    Check here for news, recent events, announcements, and much more!

    Archives

    March 2016
    September 2015
    September 2014
    July 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013

    Categories

    All

    RSS Feed

Proudly powered by Weebly